Why leaving a sugar relationship is so hard

People often know a relationship is harmful and still stay. Sunk costs, unpredictable kindness, financial dependence and shame can make leaving feel impossible even when the risks are clear.

Psychology and Boundaries·Published ·Updated ·About 3 minutes·By Zhi Yuan·Reviewed by Standards and review desk·Editorial standards

Why leaving a sugar relationship is so hard (illustration)
Sugar Circle Watch explainer

It is not simply a failure of willpower

From outside, the answer seems obvious: if you know it is bad, leave. From inside, leaving involves rent, debt, work, privacy, friends, family and physical safety.

Leaving is usually a process with starts, pauses and returns. Understanding that can replace self-blame with a realistic plan.

Sunk costs keep you invested

Time, affection, money, a move to another city or a job given up for the relationship all create pressure to keep going. The hope is that the sacrifice will eventually pay off.

In a sugar relationship, the costs can be concrete: paying someone's debt, covering rent or taking out a loan. The more you have spent, the harder it is to admit that the promised future may never arrive.

Ask yourself: if I met this person today, knowing everything I know now, would I start this relationship again?

Unpredictable kindness is the strongest hook

A consistently bad relationship is easier to leave. The hardest pattern is neglect followed by affection, a transfer after an apology, or a threat followed by tears and promises.

Intermittent rewards keep you waiting for the next good moment. The occasional kindness becomes evidence that the person 'really loves me', while the harm is explained away as an exception.

Judge the relationship by how you are treated on the worst days, not only by the best ones.

Money and housing can trap you

If the other person pays your rent, living costs or medical bills, leaving may mean immediate eviction, debt or loss of income. Financial dependence directly reduces your ability to say no.

Control over bank accounts, phone numbers, social accounts, immigration papers or private information increases the cost of leaving.

Make a concrete budget: minimum monthly expenses, possible places to stay, people you can ask, and local assistance. Turning a vague fear into numbers often makes it more manageable.

Shame keeps the problem hidden

'I chose this', 'people will judge me', 'I should have known better'. Shame discourages asking for help, and secrecy removes the support that would make leaving possible.

A person who feels isolated is easier to control. The isolation then reinforces the belief that the problem is personal.

Telling one non-judgmental person can be more useful than hearing a lecture. A friend, counsellor, legal aid worker or hotline can help you think without taking over.

Fear of retaliation is rational

Threats to publish private photos, contact family, report you to an employer or show up at your home are real risks, not overreactions.

In that situation, plan for safety before confronting the person. Save the threats, tell someone you trust, and contact the police if necessary. Do not meet alone to 'settle things'.

Physical safety comes before closure or a final conversation.

A practical exit checklist

  1. Secure evidence: Back up chats, transfers, threats and identity details somewhere the other person cannot access.
  2. Prepare resources: Set aside emergency money, identify a temporary place to stay, and gather ID, medication and essentials.
  3. Reduce digital control: Turn off location sharing, change passwords and review payment authorisations.
  4. Tell someone: Share the plan with one trusted person and agree on check-in times.
  5. Get advice: Consult a lawyer or legal aid about debts, housing, privacy and any protection order options.
If there is violence, stalking or threats, contact the police and a specialist service first. Do not handle it alone.

After leaving, ambivalence is normal

Missing the person or doubting the decision does not mean the decision was wrong. It takes time for the body and mind to adjust to safety.

Focus on small routines: eating, sleeping and getting through the day. Reduce contact and stop checking the other person's social media where possible.

If sleeplessness, panic or inability to work persists, seek a mental health assessment. Trauma responses are treatable, and you do not have to manage alone.

English edition, condensed and adapted from the Chinese original · Get help by situation · In-depth guides · Disclaimer